HTC's top designers reportedly in custody after stealing trade secrets
HTC's top designers reportedly in custody after stealing trade secrets
Internal issues aplenty at HTC
Following reports of internal disarray in May, when several executives
departed, HTC has filed a formal complaint out of its offices in
Taipei, Taiwan, that several high-level employees stole trade secrets
after planning to leaving the company. Several Chinese papers
report that HTC's VP of product design Thomas Chien, an R&D director
Wu Chien Hung, and design team senior manager Justin Huang were among
five employees that planned to leave the company after collecting their
mid-year bonuses yesterday.
Authorities raided HTC's R&D center yesterday
Engadget's Richard Lai cites
several Chinese sources as reporting that HTC "caught Chien secretly
downloading files related to the upcoming Sense 6.0 UI design" and
sharing the data with external contacts via email. Chien and Wu were
reportedly both taken into custody following raids at HTC's R&D
center and the suspects' homes and offices.
In addition to stealing trade
secrets, HTC also alleges the designers charged elevated fees for their
part in the design of HTC's One smartphone. Although the design was done
in-house, Lai reports that Chien, Wu, and Huang are accused of using
"an external design firm to invoice HTC for over $334,000" before
splitting the fee between themselves. The trio have reportedly
registered a new design company aimed at the Chinese market, where Focus Taiwan claims they're "likely to work with Chinese smartphone vendors to develop new models, using the technology they stole from HTC." According to the China Post,
one suspect at the scene of the R&D raid claimed HTC management was
aware of the new business and questioned the reason for the search. It
should be noted that, while UDN agrees with the chain of events, it doesn't attribute the comments to suspect, but rather an onlooker.
The problems are two-fold for HTC
The problems are two-fold for
HTC. As well as allegedly dealing with a major issue of internal fraud,
the company also looks likely to lose some very important members of its
design team. Huang personally sketched out the design for the HTC One,
while Chien spearheads the entire product design team in Taiwan. HTC
hasn't commented on any of the revelations, apart from to note that "the
matter is under investigation by relevant authorities."
Update: HTC has
elaborated on its previous statement, telling us that it "expects
employees to observe and practice the highest levels of integrity and
ethics. Protecting the company’s proprietary and intellectual
properties, privacy and security is a core fundamental responsibility of
every employee. The company does not condone any violation. As this
matter is currently under investigation by the relevant authorities, we
therefore refrain from further comments."